M•A•C Zoom Fast Black Lash VS Lancôme Hypnôse Drama in Excessive Black

Hello guys and dolls! Welcome to my first ever comparative review! Today I decided to compare two products that I own samples of that claim to give similar results to one another. 

I'm going to rate each product out of five for different categories and the highest score wins!

Let's get started! 

M•A•C Zoom Fast Black Lash

Before and After I used M•A•C Zoom Fast Black Lash

 This mascara claims to "saturate lashes with the richest black ever" and "separate each lash".
Since my lashes are already black, we're unable to see if it darkens lashes as effectively as it claims to. 

I estimate a length increase of about 40%! I also found this mascara to be quite clumpy and my lashes difficult to separate while I was wearing it. Has anyone had this problem before?

• Blackness: 4/5 (hard to tell)
• Softness of eyelashes post-removal: 3/5
• Increase of lash volume:  2/5
• Lash Separation: 2/5
• "WOW!" effect: 3.5/5
• Total: 14.5

 Lancôme Hypnôse Drama in Excessive Black

This mascara claims to "increase lash volume up to 6 times", "leave lashes soft and supple" and "provide perfect lash separation". This mascara left my eyelashes longer than they have ever been! A possible 45%-50% length increase and less clumping than the  M•A•C Zoom Fast Black Lash. Not to pick favourites (which I probably am) but so far I'm preferring this mascara!

• Blackness: 4/5 (hard to tell)
• Softness of eyelashes post-removal: 4/5
• Increase of lash volume:  3/5
• Lash Separation: 3/5
• "WOW!" effect: 4/5
• Total: 18!

WE HAVE A WINNER!

In my opinion, Lancôme Hypnôse Drama in Excessive Black is the better mascara (and my new favourite). 

Does anyone agree or disagree with me? What are your opinions?